That episode was a complete mess. The pacing was dizzying. New things were brought in so fast that by the end of the episode I had no idea what was going on, what any character wanted, or what anything meant. I just had an endless stream of questions as I was watching the episode – none of which were answered, so for this review, I’m just going to list them all:
- How are they able to travel through a Borg transwarp conduit without a transwarp coil? Or do they have a transwarp coil? Do all Federation ships have them now? Did they get them from the Artefact? If they do have a transwarp coil then, why is their ship shaking so much as it goes through the conduit?
- Why does Picard decide to bring Narek onto their ship immediately when it’s so obviously a trick and Soji even says she thinks it’s a trick? Since when would Picard fall for such an obvious ploy?
- No-one ever explains these flower things. What are they? How do they make them? Are they living things? How do they survive in space? Are the flowers meant to crash ships into the ground, or was that an accident? Can the flowers only do this by dying? How do they control the flowers? Do the flowers control themselves? Do the flowers have free will? How do you even ‘make’ a flower anyway – don’t they mean ‘grow’?
- Apparently crashing through an atmosphere is a viable way of getting down to the ground.
- Picard is apparently going to die, and I don’t know what the point of this is.
- Soji remembers things whenever it’s convenient to the plot. Is she going to get all her memories back at some point, or will she just have hazy memories forever? How are these memories even being blocked? Why does no-one question it? Why does no-one ever ask her to just tell them everything she knows?
- Somehow a large part of the cube survived the landing.
- Apparently Seven enjoyed being a Borg again for a bit. This massively, massively undermines the Borg as a threat.
- The gang leaves the Borg cube within minutes of arriving, making the whole thing seem pointless.
- Why does Elnor stay with the Borg when he clearly wants to go with Picard?
- Five strangers walk into the android’s village and no-one asks them who they are for several minutes.
- All of the androids in the village look more like Data than either Soji or Dahj. Why? Why did they make Soji and Dahj differently? And how?
- Why are the androids fascinated by how old Picard is? Soong is there and he’s just as old.
- How does Altan Soong look identical to Noonian Soong? (Some have speculated that it’s actually Lore.)
- Why didn’t the androids make more flowers? Why did they think fifteen was enough? What else are they doing all day?
- Why is Picard not there when Soji explains everything?
- Why did they block Soji’s memories in the first place if it was possible that she might accidentally reveal the location of the planet? Why was it necessary to block her memories at all? How were they expecting Soji to return to the planet if all of this hadn’t have happened?
- Why doesn’t Soji just remember everything now that she’s back in the village? Is anyone going to help her get her memories back at all?
- It turns out it was stupid for the Romulans to grab onto that glowing handrail.
- Why did the robots only have one ship? And why didn’t they make another one after the first one was destroyed?
- How the hell is Sutra able to do the Mind Meld? She looks like a Soong-type mechanical android – I thought they couldn’t interact psychically with anything? Thinking about it, Troi couldn’t empathically sense Soji, so even Soji shouldn’t be able to do it.
- Why does Sutra decide to do a Mind Meld even though it might drive her mad too? At this point it’s only a hypothesis that this information was intended for androids. And a psychopathic synthetic is far more dangerous than a homicidal human.
- Sutra claims that ‘organics’ hate robots because they don’t age, which is not something that has ever been suggested by anyone so far in this series.
- If the super-beings are always watching, why do they need a special signal to know when to come?
- Everyone condemns Jurati as being a bad person for killing Maddox, even though they all agree that she had been driven mad by the Romulans.
- Also, everyone seems to be over the fact that Jurati killed Maddox – they can’t seem to decide whether they like her or not from one scene to the next.
- The robots have a tool that can repair your ship with imagination, but apparently can’t build a fucking ship.
- Picard says he has a ‘first contact situation’, but is it really first contact when Maddox and Soong have been there for a while?
- Why do Picard and Soji discuss the moral implications of Jurati killing Maddox when she was brainwashed?
- Why does Narek run to the Borg cube? Don’t they all hate him there too?
- Did Saga just lose an eye? How did she die from that – she’s a robot?
- Is Sutra in charge? Why is Sutra the one that’s in charge?
- Jurati is apparently over her brainwashing now. And the psychic block that didn’t last more than a few minutes. How? Why?
- And probably the most annoying thing in this episode: the Romulans were right. They tried to understand some information intended for synthetic minds; it drove them mad, and apparently they got it wrong; but they actually got it right – if the galaxy keeps making androids, eventually the super-beings will come and destroy them all. It’s extreme dramatic dissonance, where the audience can see that the Romulans got it right, but the show is telling us the opposite.